A few weeks ago I toyed with the idea to look for a local sequencer software, because my beloved Splice sequencer sadly is just too buggy: playback glitches, frozen browser and even memory access violations; sometimes had to close a hanging Firefox by the taskmanager.
So I checked different demo apps like FruityLoops, Reaper or Magix. Well, after hours of playing around I found they're all very fine, but seemed too complex for me to handle.
Anyway, last week the Splice server went down for unknown reasons and is still off today. Maybe they (actually Bram, who is the only one left) are preparing kinda new relaunch, or maybe Splice is history. Even if they come back, I can't imagine the sequencer is much updated - there's just no dev team anymore.
So I picked Reaper as a nice candidate and reinstalled it. There's a large community/forum behind and quite active developers, you can say there's almost weekly updates. Finally I could start mixing my new song. And I had the additional feature of MIDI/VSTi, which I was pretty much happy about, because we all know of its flexibilities. But...
... while Reaper's audio features are highly sophisticated, its MIDI implementation/features aren't that perfect: especially the use of VSTi is still buggy in some situations, resulting in a glitchy playback in which peaks and noises make it almost impossible to work with. At least the rendering works fine...
As a workaround I may have to convert my MIDI to audio (by extarnal tools like Synthfont) before it can be used in Reaper, so it will be a similar procedure as before, when I worked with the Splice sequencer.
What a pity... the world is looking forward to drop a man on mars, but we poor musicians still have to fight with lousy DAWs, haha.
Comments
heh
good to hear you found something good for you
i don't know how good reaper is .. heard some good reviews .. and tested it ..but it's too late for me .. i am to familiar with FL now :)
Reaper
I've been using Reaper for a while now. I mostly just use it as a multi-track, not too much midi though. It's been working well for me so far.
Reaper
It's your computer that cant keep up, all vsti's take huge amounts of memory . On all of my songs the rhythm tracks are vsti's rendered to waves and then mixed into a wave for there final mixed sound . My computer is old and will only do one track at a time . My buddy who owns a pro studio says even his new Mac will only do so many before it gets buggy. I just listen to the full mix midi through my PC's midi to tell if I like it and then sample each track. It is the same but with much more cool sounds after it has been sampled. I use Battery 2 (Native Instruments ) for drums ,Super Quartet (Edirol) for pianos and basses ,FM7 (Native Instruments 4 Yamaha) Wavestation (Korg) for synth sounds and synth Basses . I have several others that I have not used in a long time that I didn't like as well. I don't use effects until they are waves because that is even more memory used . Even then I don't use them without transforming them to the wave ,as my computer too wimpy to use them as plugins . The multitrack mixdown is where I add guitar and harmonica parts in real time .
Sequencing, another approach
Yes, this will probably the way I create my next songs:
1. Preparing all needed backing patterns in MIDI (using Noteworthy).
2. Converting all MIDIs to WAVs (using Synthfont and optionally various soundfonts/sf2 or VSTi).
3. Assembling and mixing basic elements to a draft WAV (using Audacity).
4. Recording solo vocals/guitar/harp/etc over playback (using GuitarRig).
5. Postprocessing, mixdown and export via Audacity.
These are indeed four different tools to get the work done, but at least they're fairly stable and almost errorfree, and I'm familiar with'em.